A new piece is up now at allvoices.com. You can read it by clicking here.
Hamas: Throwing Gazans Into The Fire
April 20, 2008 by Mitchell Plitnick
Posted in Carter, Gaza, Hamas, Israel, Palestine, Terrorism | Tagged Carter, Gaza, Hamas, Israel, Kerem Shalom, Mesha'al, Meshal, Middle east, Nahal Oz, Palestinian, Schalit, siege, Terrorism | 3 Comments
3 Responses
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Feedburner
Speaker
Do you need an expert speaker on Israel-Palestine, the history of the conflict, the US-Israel relationship, the different sectors of the peace movement, and many other topics related to Israel-Palestine?
Use the contact form here to contact me to speak to your group, on your panel or at your event.
Follow me on Twitter
- 'Anonymous' hacker group threatens 'reign of terror' against Israel http://t.co/wjhQJS2t #fb Video included. Seems serious. 3 hours ago
- ISR to mull tax exemptions on donations to Zionist settlement http://t.co/JOPd19xI #fb Belying claim that gov can't stop settlement growth. 8 hours ago
- The MEK are terrorists, despite the fact that some of our less noble congresspeople support them. http://t.co/vYCUHEtg #fb 8 hours ago
- Hamas's Gaza-based leadership challenges Palestinian unity deal http://t.co/9au5iU5R #fb 1 day ago
- Bibi's "threat" to cut off talks with a unified Palestinian government may hold hope for a way forward. http://t.co/IgjvGnja #fb #in 1 day ago
Blogs
- Bernard Avishai Dot Com
- Dove’s Eye View
- Emily L. Hauser – In My Head
- Juan Cole: Informed Comment
- Leonard Fein: The Conversation
- Mondoweiss
- Muzzlewatch
- Prospects for Peace
- Realistic Dove
- Realistic Peace In Israel-Palestine (Moshe Yaroni)
- Shalom Rav
- South Jerusalem
- The Magnes Zionist
- The Mideast Peace Pulse
- Tikkun Olam
- Wish You Orwell–The Decline and Fall of the Israeli Democracy
Favorite Sites
- Ameinu
- American Task Force On Palestine
- Americans for Peace Now
- B’Tselem
- Bat Shalom
- Churches for Middle East Peace
- Combatants For Peace
- Gush Shalom
- Hamoked
- J Street
- Jewish Voice for Peace
- Jews On First
- Meretz USA
- New Israel Fund
- Rabbis for Human Rights
- Rabbis for Human Rights: North America
- Ray Hanania’s Home Page
- The Mideast Peace Pulse
- Uri Avnery’s news pages
- Yesh Din
News Sources
Categories
Archives
Meta
-
Recent Posts
Not bad.
People have commented that I need to learn to take “yes” for an answer. So I will make that effort here and do the minimum objecting to the piece.
But I must interject: What is your plan Mitchell?
You do a good job of telling everyone else what they are doing wrong and even a good job of trying to be balanced in doing so. But you propose no alternatives. As long as the rockets fly into Israeli civilian neighborhoods, the Israelis feel they must do something. How wrong are they in that conclusion? How many nations would do nothing?? Your beef seems to be concerned with the nature of the Israeli counter-measures. OK, lets, arguendo, assume that there is fault in the Israeli response. You are now Prime Minister of Israel with a mandate and 70% approval. What you do?? Talk to Hamas?? OK. That was fun. Now what?? Give Hamas their demands?? Your approval then drops to 7%. What’s the fix??My suggestion is that the USA tell Egypt to take over (annex) Gaza, or their aid package goes to Israel. If they cooperate, the USA will bonus them with some light military equipment.
Problem solved. Then we could move onto some really important issues. Like fixing the US Judicial system.
Can Trollstein comment on how the Egyptians’ taking over Gaza would solve the rocket attack issues?
Mo:
They would essentially have to clean-streets and disarm all non-officials. This would not by easy. But, someone will have to do this, either now or later. If fellow Arabs take charge, at least, the race-card will have beed removed from the equation. There will still be some who still claim that the Egypt leadership are “Jews” and or “Keffirs”, but I’ll take that over the much larger and louder cries of “war crimes” and masacres.